5/5 - (1 vote)

Substack vs ConvertKit: Choose the Best Email Platform for Your Business

Email marketing platforms are a dime a dozen, but when it comes to growing a subscriber base, monetizing content, and streamlining campaigns, two names dominate the conversation: Substack and ConvertKit. Both platforms cater to creators, marketers, and writers, but their features, pricing, and overall usability differ significantly.

In this in-depth Substack vs ConvertKit comparison, we’ll explore each platform’s features, pros, cons, and unique advantages to help you decide which is better, Substack or ConvertKit, for your needs.

Whether you’re a beginner looking to build your first newsletter or a professional marketer aiming to automate and monetize campaigns, this guide will break it all down.

Substack and ConvertKit

Substack

Substack is an email newsletter platform tailored for independent writers, creators, and journalists. Launched in 2017, Substack gained popularity for allowing writers to publish, grow their audience, and monetize through paid subscriptions—all without needing technical expertise. In essence, it empowers creators to focus purely on content without worrying about website design or coding.

Substack’s appeal lies in its simplicity. It’s a platform that merges blogging and email into one seamless experience, perfect for writers looking to engage audiences directly and earn revenue through subscriptions.

ConvertKit

ConvertKit, on the other hand, is an email marketing platform designed specifically for creators, marketers, and small businesses. Founded in 2013, ConvertKit goes beyond newsletters, offering advanced features such as email automation, audience segmentation, landing pages, and detailed analytics.

ConvertKit is perfect for creators who want to leverage email marketing as a growth engine while retaining control over monetization strategies. It’s a robust platform that combines user-friendly design with powerful tools for scaling campaigns and growing audiences.

Substack Features: Simplicity and Monetization

Substack’s greatest strength is its simplicity. Unlike traditional email platforms, Substack removes the technical hurdles, allowing users to start a newsletter in minutes. Below are the key Substack features:

Easy-to-Use Interface

Substack requires no technical skills or coding knowledge. The interface is straightforward, with minimal distractions-making it ideal for writers who want to focus on content.

Subscription Management

Substack simplifies monetization with integrated paid subscriptions. You can offer free or paid tiers, and Substack handles payment processing seamlessly.

Built-In Blog Integration

Each Substack newsletter also functions as a blog. Your emails are archived online, allowing audiences to discover past newsletters through search engines.

Audience Engagement

Readers can comment on newsletters and share their thoughts directly with writers. This builds stronger engagement between creators and subscribers.

Seamless Monetization

Substack’s biggest draw is its ability to help writers make money. The platform takes care of subscriptions, payments, and revenue management-making it a great option for creators looking to monetize quickly.

ConvertKit Features: Automation and Advanced Email Tools

ConvertKit is built with creators in mind, offering features that go far beyond what Substack provides. If you’re focused on growth, segmentation, and email automation, ConvertKit might be your top choice. Here are the key ConvertKit features:

Email Automation

ConvertKit shines with its advanced email automation tools. Users can create email sequences, autoresponders, and automated workflows to nurture leads and drive conversions.

Audience Segmentation

Unlike Substack, ConvertKit allows users to tag and segment their audience based on behavior, interests, or actions. This enables highly targeted campaigns.

Customizable Opt-In Forms and Landing Pages

ConvertKit includes beautiful, customizable landing pages and sign-up forms to help you capture leads and grow your email list effectively.

Advanced Analytics

ConvertKit offers detailed reporting on email performance, subscriber activity, and revenue tracking-essential for professional marketers.

Flexible Monetization Options

While Substack focuses on subscriptions, ConvertKit gives users more control. Creators can sell digital products, courses, or services directly through ConvertKit.

Substack Pricing vs ConvertKit Pricing Plans

Substack Pricing

Substack follows a simple, creator-friendly pricing model:

Free Plan: Substack is free to use for publishing newsletters and building an audience.
Paid Subscriptions: Substack takes a 10% commission on paid subscriptions.

This commission-based model works well for beginners since there are no upfront costs. However, for creators with a large paying audience, the 10% fee can add up.

ConvertKit Pricing

ConvertKit offers a tiered pricing structure, making it scalable as your audience grows:

Free Plan: Up to 1,000 subscribers, basic features.
Creator Plan: Starts at $9/month for up to 300 subscribers. Offers advanced email automation, landing pages, and more.
Creator Pro: Starts at $25/month. Includes additional features like advanced reporting, subscriber scoring, and referral systems.

ConvertKit’s pricing is flexible, and it doesn’t take a percentage of your earnings—making it a better option for creators focused on monetization at scale.

Substack vs ConvertKit for Beginners

When choosing between Substack vs ConvertKit for beginners, simplicity and ease of use often take center stage. Here’s a closer look at how both platforms serve new users.

Substack for Beginners

Substack is incredibly beginner-friendly. With no setup complexities, technical knowledge, or design experience required, anyone can start a newsletter within minutes. This simplicity makes Substack perfect for creators, writers, and journalists looking to dive straight into publishing without worrying about tools or integrations.

Additionally, Substack’s monetization feature is straightforward—users can toggle between free and paid subscriptions easily.

Pros for Beginners:

Intuitive user interface
No upfront costs
Easy subscription setup

Cons for Beginners:

Limited customization options
No advanced tools like automation or segmentation

ConvertKit for Beginners

ConvertKit, while feature-rich, has a slightly steeper learning curve for beginners. However, ConvertKit’s step-by-step guides, onboarding tutorials, and customer support make it accessible for new users. The platform’s free plan (up to 1,000 subscribers) allows beginners to test the waters without committing to paid features immediately.

Pros for Beginners:

Access to professional tools like landing pages and opt-in forms
Free plan with generous subscriber limits
Excellent tutorials and community support

Cons for Beginners:

Requires time to learn and set up automation features
Slightly more complex than Substack

Substack vs ConvertKit for Monetization

For creators and marketers, monetization is often the deciding factor when comparing Substack vs ConvertKit. Both platforms enable earning opportunities, but they take different approaches.

Substack for Monetization

Substack simplifies monetization with its built-in paid subscriptions. Writers can publish free content to attract readers and then offer exclusive, premium content behind a paywall. Substack handles all payment processing through Stripe and charges a 10% commission on earnings.

Key Advantages:

Easy to set up paid subscriptions
Allows free and premium content tiers
No technical setup required

Limitations:

The 10% commission can be costly for large-scale creators
Limited options for selling additional products or services

ConvertKit for Monetization

ConvertKit provides greater flexibility for monetization. Creators can sell digital products, memberships, courses, and even services directly through ConvertKit. Unlike Substack, ConvertKit does not charge a commission, making it a more profitable choice for scaling monetization efforts.

Key Advantages:

Multiple revenue streams: subscriptions, digital products, and more
No revenue commission
Integrates with e-commerce tools for expanded sales

Limitations:

Requires more setup compared to Substack
Advanced features are only available on paid plans

Substack vs ConvertKit for Writers and Creators

Both platforms cater to writers and creators, but their strengths serve different goals.

Substack for Writers

Substack is designed specifically for writers, making it a natural fit for those focused on creating and monetizing newsletters. It eliminates distractions and lets creators focus solely on writing. Additionally, Substack’s blog-like archive helps writers build a long-term audience and gain discoverability through search engines.

Why Writers Love Substack:

Perfect for long-form content and newsletters
Built-in community and engagement tools (comments, shares)
No learning curve

Substack Limitations for Writers:

Limited customization options
Not ideal for advanced marketing

ConvertKit for Creators

ConvertKit appeals to creators who want to do more than just write. It’s ideal for those looking to scale their business by selling courses, products, or coaching services alongside email marketing. With automation, segmentation, and analytics tools, ConvertKit empowers creators to grow faster and connect more deeply with their audience.

Why Creators Love ConvertKit:

Flexible monetization options
Advanced audience targeting and analytics
Tools for creators selling digital products

ConvertKit Limitations for Creators:

Requires more time to master advanced features
May be overkill for writers focused solely on newsletters

Pros and Cons: Substack

Let’s break down the Substack pros and cons:

Substack Pros

Easy to Use: Intuitive interface with no setup required.
Seamless Monetization: Built-in paid subscriptions.
Low Barrier to Entry: No upfront costs; free to start.
Blog-Like Archive: Newsletters are stored online for better discoverability.
Great for Writers: Perfect for those focused on writing and engagement.

Substack Cons

High Commission: 10% fee on all paid subscriptions.
Limited Customization: Basic templates and no branding options.
No Automation Tools: Lacks advanced email automation or segmentation features.
Not Ideal for Marketing: Limited tools for audience growth and analytics.

Pros and Cons: ConvertKit

Here’s a closer look at ConvertKit pros and cons:

ConvertKit Pros

Powerful Automation: Advanced email workflows and sequences.
Audience Segmentation: Target specific subscriber groups with precision.
Flexible Monetization: Sell subscriptions, digital products, or services.
Free Plan: Generous free plan for up to 1,000 subscribers.
Landing Pages and Forms: Built-in tools to capture leads and grow lists.

ConvertKit Cons

Learning Curve: Advanced features require time to master.
Paid Plans: Access to full features requires a paid subscription.
Overkill for Writers: Some features may be unnecessary for simple newsletters.

Which is the Best Email Platform in 2024 and Beyond?

When comparing Substack vs ConvertKit in 2024, the answer depends on your needs and goals as a creator or marketer.

Choose Substack If:

You are a writer focused on building a paid newsletter audience.
You want a simple platform with no technical hurdles.
Monetizing through subscriptions is your primary goal.

Choose ConvertKit If:

You are a creator or marketer looking to grow and scale your audience.
You need advanced tools like email automation, segmentation, and analytics.
You want to sell digital products, courses, or services alongside newsletters.

For writers and creators starting with newsletters, Substack’s simplicity is unbeatable. However, if you plan to scale, automate, and diversify monetization, ConvertKit’s flexibility and robust tools make it the better option.

Conclusion

In the debate of Substack vs ConvertKit, both platforms have their strengths. Substack excels at simplicity and direct monetization, making it the ideal choice for independent writers. On the other hand, ConvertKit offers powerful tools for automation, segmentation, and multi-channel monetization-making it the go-to choice for creators looking to grow their business.

When choosing between Substack or ConvertKit, consider your goals: Are you focused purely on writing and subscriptions, or do you need advanced tools to scale your email marketing efforts?

Both platforms remain top contenders as the best email platforms for 2024 and beyond. Whether you’re a beginner, writer, or marketer, this guide has equipped you to make an informed decision.

So, take your pick-Substack for simplicity and writing or ConvertKit for growth and automation. Either way, your email marketing journey is set for success.